logo

Any question:

+357 22 476 800

AMERICAN MEDICAL CENTRE

215, Spyrou Kyprianou Avenue 2047 Strovolos, Nicosia, Cyprus.

Surgical Treatment of Hemorrhoids: Techniques, Benefits, Risks, and How They Compare

Hemorrhoids are swollen vascular cushions in the lower rectum and anus. They are a normal part of human anatomy, but they can become enlarged, inflamed, prolapsed, thrombosed, or prone to bleeding. Although many patients improve with fiber, hydration, topical medication, and other conservative measures, surgery may be appropriate when symptoms are severe, persistent, recurrent, or unresponsive to less invasive treatments.

Several surgical and procedural options are available. They differ considerably in terms of pain, recovery time, recurrence risk, suitability for internal or external hemorrhoids, and long-term effectiveness. The most appropriate procedure depends on the grade of the hemorrhoids, the presence of external disease, the patient’s symptoms, general health, and the surgeon’s experience.

This guide focuses on the main surgical techniques and compares their advantages and limitations.

When Is Hemorrhoid Surgery Considered?

Surgery is not usually the first treatment for uncomplicated hemorrhoids. Doctors generally begin with lifestyle measures and, when appropriate, office-based procedures. Surgical treatment may be recommended when a patient has:

  • Large or prolapsing internal hemorrhoids
  • Grade III or grade IV hemorrhoids
  • Hemorrhoids that cannot be pushed back into the rectum
  • Significant external hemorrhoids
  • Combined internal and external hemorrhoids
  • Recurrent bleeding despite non-surgical treatment
  • Persistent pain, irritation, hygiene difficulties, or mucus discharge
  • A thrombosed external hemorrhoid causing severe acute pain

Before treatment, rectal bleeding should be properly evaluated. Although hemorrhoids are a common cause of bright-red bleeding, bleeding may also result from colorectal polyps, inflammatory bowel disease, diverticular disease, anal fissures, or colorectal cancer.

Understanding Hemorrhoid Grades

Internal hemorrhoids are commonly classified into four grades:

  • Grade I: Enlarged hemorrhoids that remain inside the rectum
  • Grade II: Prolapse during bowel movements but return spontaneously
  • Grade III: Prolapse during bowel movements and require manual replacement
  • Grade IV: Permanently prolapsed and cannot be pushed back inside

Office-based procedures are often effective for Grade I and Grade II hemorrhoids. Some Grade III hemorrhoids may also respond to these treatments, but larger, recurrent, or mixed hemorrhoids are more likely to require an operation.

1. Conventional Hemorrhoidectomy

What is it?

A conventional hemorrhoidectomy involves surgically removing the hemorrhoidal tissue. The surgeon identifies the enlarged hemorrhoidal columns, removes them, and either leaves the wounds open to heal naturally or closes them with sutures.

This operation is generally performed under regional or general anesthesia, although the exact approach varies.

Open and closed hemorrhoidectomy

The two traditional forms are:

  • Open hemorrhoidectomy: The surgical wounds are left open to heal gradually.
  • Closed hemorrhoidectomy: The wounds are partially or completely closed with sutures.

Both techniques are used to treat substantial internal, external, or combined hemorrhoidal disease. The choice often depends on the surgeon’s preference, the number and location of hemorrhoids, and the condition of the surrounding tissue.

Advantages

Conventional hemorrhoidectomy is considered one of the most definitive treatments for advanced hemorrhoids. Its advantages include:

  • High long-term effectiveness
  • Particularly useful for Grade III and Grade IV disease
  • Suitable for large external or mixed hemorrhoids
  • Can remove excess tissue directly
  • Lower long-term recurrence than some less invasive procedures

Disadvantages

The main limitation is postoperative discomfort. Recovery may involve:

  • Significant pain, especially during bowel movements
  • Bleeding or minor discharge
  • Difficulty sitting comfortably
  • Temporary difficulty urinating
  • Several weeks before full recovery
  • A need for careful stool-softening and pain-control measures

Modern anesthesia, local nerve blocks, multimodal pain relief, and improved surgical techniques may reduce discomfort, but hemorrhoidectomy remains the most painful of the commonly used surgical options for many patients.

Who may benefit most?

Conventional hemorrhoidectomy is often considered the preferred option for:

  • Large Grade III or Grade IV hemorrhoids
  • Substantial external hemorrhoids
  • Mixed internal and external disease
  • Recurrent hemorrhoids after less invasive treatment
  • Patients seeking the lowest possible risk of recurrence

2. Stapled Hemorrhoidopexy

What is it?

Stapled hemorrhoidopexy is designed primarily for prolapsing internal hemorrhoids. Instead of removing the hemorrhoids directly, the surgeon removes a circular strip of mucosa above the hemorrhoidal tissue using a circular stapling device.

This pulls the prolapsed tissue upward and interrupts part of its blood supply. The hemorrhoidal tissue generally becomes smaller over time.

Advantages

Compared with conventional hemorrhoidectomy, stapled hemorrhoidopexy may provide:

  • Less pain during the early recovery period
  • A faster return to normal activities
  • Less disruption to the sensitive skin around the anus
  • Reduced external wounds

Limitations

Stapled hemorrhoidopexy is not usually appropriate for significant external hemorrhoids because it does not remove external skin or external hemorrhoidal tissue. It may also be less suitable when there is extensive fibrosis or very advanced prolapse.

A major consideration is recurrence. Because the hemorrhoids are repositioned rather than completely excised, recurrent prolapse or bleeding may occur more often than after conventional hemorrhoidectomy.

Rare but serious complications have also been reported, including:

  • Severe pelvic or rectal pain
  • Significant bleeding
  • Infection
  • Narrowing of the rectum
  • Urgency or changes in bowel function
  • Rare injury to nearby pelvic structures

Who may benefit most?

Stapled hemorrhoidopexy may be considered for selected patients with:

  • Predominantly internal hemorrhoids
  • Significant mucosal or hemorrhoidal prolapse
  • Limited external disease
  • A preference for potentially easier early recovery

The decision should be individualized because lower early pain does not necessarily mean better long-term outcomes.

3. Doppler-Guided Hemorrhoidal Artery Ligation

What is it?

Doppler-guided hemorrhoidal artery ligation, sometimes called transanal hemorrhoidal dearterialization, uses a small Doppler ultrasound probe to identify arteries supplying the hemorrhoids. The surgeon then ties off these arteries with sutures.

In some cases, the prolapsed tissue is also lifted and secured upward in a process known as mucopexy or hemorrhoidopexy.

Advantages

Potential benefits include:

  • No large external incision
  • Less tissue removal
  • Usually less postoperative pain than conventional hemorrhoidectomy
  • Shorter recovery for some patients
  • Useful for bleeding internal hemorrhoids

The procedure may be performed as day surgery, depending on the patient and local practice.

Limitations

Artery ligation may be less effective for very large external hemorrhoids or advanced prolapse. Some patients require additional mucopexy to correct prolapse. Recurrence may also be higher than after excisional hemorrhoidectomy, particularly in advanced disease.

Possible complications include:

  • Postoperative pain or pressure
  • Bleeding
  • Temporary urgency
  • Incomplete correction of prolapse
  • Recurrent hemorrhoids
  • The need for repeat treatment

Who may benefit most?

This technique may be suitable for patients with:

  • Internal hemorrhoids associated with bleeding
  • Mild-to-moderate prolapse
  • A desire to avoid tissue excision
  • A need for a less painful alternative to traditional surgery

It may be less appropriate for severe external or combined hemorrhoidal disease.

4. Radiofrequency or Energy-Based Procedures

Some centers use radiofrequency, bipolar energy, or other controlled-energy devices to reduce hemorrhoidal tissue. These techniques may be marketed as minimally invasive surgery or “tissue-sparing” treatments.

The exact method varies. Energy may be applied to hemorrhoidal tissue to cause shrinkage, scarring, and reduction of blood flow.

Potential advantages

  • Small treatment area
  • Limited tissue removal
  • Often performed as an outpatient procedure
  • Potentially less pain than conventional hemorrhoidectomy
  • Shorter return-to-work period in selected patients

Limitations

The evidence and long-term outcomes vary between devices and techniques. Not all energy-based procedures are equally established, and availability differs by country and medical center.

Potential disadvantages include:

  • Recurrence, particularly in advanced prolapse
  • Postoperative bleeding
  • Incomplete symptom relief
  • Need for repeat intervention
  • Higher cost in some settings

Patients should ask the surgeon which specific device is being used, what evidence supports it, and how its recurrence rates compare with established treatments.

5. Excision of a Thrombosed External Hemorrhoid

A thrombosed external hemorrhoid occurs when a blood clot forms within a vein under the skin around the anus. It can cause sudden, severe pain and a firm, bluish lump.

In selected patients, especially when the clot is recent and symptoms are severe, a doctor may remove the clot and overlying hemorrhoidal tissue through a small procedure. This can provide rapid relief.

If the thrombosis is already improving, conservative care may be preferable. Treatment may include:

  • Warm sitz baths
  • Pain medication when medically appropriate
  • Stool softeners
  • Fiber and adequate fluid intake
  • Avoidance of straining

This procedure is different from a full hemorrhoidectomy and is generally used for acute thrombosis rather than chronic internal hemorrhoidal disease.

Comparison of Common Surgical Techniques

Technique Best suited for Early pain Recovery Recurrence tendency External hemorrhoids treated?
Conventional hemorrhoidectomy Large, advanced, mixed, or recurrent hemorrhoids Higher Longer Generally lower Yes
Stapled hemorrhoidopexy Prolapsing internal hemorrhoids Usually lower Usually faster May be higher Usually no
Doppler-guided artery ligation Bleeding internal hemorrhoids with mild-to-moderate prolapse Low to moderate Relatively fast May be higher in advanced disease No
Energy-based procedures Selected internal hemorrhoids Low to moderate Often short Depends on technique and disease severity Usually limited
Thrombosed hemorrhoid excision Recent, severely painful external thrombosis Relief may be rapid Short Does not prevent future hemorrhoids Treats the acute external clot

No single procedure is best for every patient. A technique with a shorter recovery may carry a higher likelihood of recurrence, while a more extensive operation may provide better long-term control but require more postoperative care.

How Surgeons Choose the Appropriate Procedure

The decision is usually based on several factors:

Hemorrhoid severity

Small internal hemorrhoids may not need surgery. Advanced prolapse, extensive external tissue, or recurrent symptoms may favor conventional hemorrhoidectomy.

Internal versus external disease

Procedures such as stapled hemorrhoidopexy and artery ligation mainly address internal hemorrhoids. They do not reliably remove large external components.

Main symptom

The dominant symptom matters. For example:

  • Bleeding may respond to artery ligation or another internal procedure.
  • Significant prolapse may require hemorrhoidopexy or excision.
  • Large external tissue may favor conventional hemorrhoidectomy.
  • Sudden severe pain from thrombosis may require clot excision.

Previous treatment

Patients who have already undergone banding or other procedures may need a different approach if symptoms have returned.

Recovery priorities

People with work, caregiving, or mobility limitations may prioritize a quicker early recovery. However, the possibility of recurrence and future procedures should also be discussed.

Recovery After Hemorrhoid Surgery

Postoperative instructions vary, but common recommendations include:

  • Use prescribed pain medication according to instructions.
  • Keep stools soft with fiber, fluids, and stool-softening medication if recommended.
  • Avoid straining and prolonged sitting on the toilet.
  • Take warm baths when advised.
  • Keep the area clean without aggressive rubbing.
  • Increase physical activity gradually.
  • Avoid heavy lifting until the surgeon confirms it is safe.
  • Attend follow-up appointments.

Some bleeding, swelling, mucus discharge, and discomfort can be expected. However, heavy bleeding, fever, worsening pain, inability to urinate, dizziness, or signs of infection require prompt medical attention.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Which hemorrhoid surgery has the lowest recurrence rate?

Conventional excisional hemorrhoidectomy generally offers the most durable treatment for advanced hemorrhoids, particularly when external or mixed disease is present. Less invasive procedures may involve less pain but can have higher recurrence rates, especially in severe prolapse.

2. Is stapled hemorrhoidopexy better than traditional hemorrhoidectomy?

Not necessarily. Stapled hemorrhoidopexy may cause less early pain and allow a faster initial recovery, but it may have a greater risk of recurrent prolapse or bleeding. Traditional hemorrhoidectomy is often more definitive for large, advanced, or mixed hemorrhoids.

3. How long does recovery from hemorrhoidectomy take?

Many patients need several days to two weeks before returning to lighter daily activities, while complete recovery may take several weeks. The duration depends on the number and size of hemorrhoids removed, the surgical technique, general health, and the nature of the patient’s work.

4. Are laser hemorrhoid procedures always less painful?

Not necessarily. “Laser hemorrhoid treatment” can refer to different techniques, and results vary. Some patients experience less pain and a faster recovery, but the long-term effectiveness may not match conventional excision in advanced disease. Ask the surgeon about the exact procedure and its evidence.

5. Can hemorrhoids come back after surgery?

Yes. Surgery treats existing hemorrhoidal tissue but does not eliminate the factors that contribute to hemorrhoids. Maintaining adequate fiber intake, drinking enough fluids, exercising, avoiding straining, and treating constipation can reduce the risk of recurrence.

Conclusion

Hemorrhoid surgery should be selected according to the type and severity of disease rather than based solely on the promise of a quick recovery. Conventional hemorrhoidectomy remains one of the most effective options for large, advanced, external, or recurrent hemorrhoids. Stapled hemorrhoidopexy and Doppler-guided artery ligation may offer less postoperative discomfort for carefully selected patients with predominantly internal disease. Energy-based and other minimally invasive techniques can also be useful, but their suitability and long-term results vary.

A consultation with a colorectal surgeon is important before choosing a procedure. The discussion should include expected pain, recovery time, recurrence risk, possible complications, cost, and whether the technique treats internal disease, external disease, or both.